Located in Charleston, IL | Serving Central Illinois
Pagliai's Pizza - Logo


Read Testimonials From Our Satisfied Customers

Take a moment to read through some of our testimonials and see what our happy customers have to say about Pagliai's Pizza.
Count on over 50 years of experience, our commitment to quality, and fresh ingredients to give you a dining experience like no other. Check out our Wednesday specials. Visit us today!

Rate your service
If you have visited us recently, please take a moment to let us know how your experience was. We look forward to hearing from you! 
Their crust is always thin and perfect, the cheese wonderfully melty, and the atmosphere hasn't changed since the 1950s.

- Renee G. - Iowa City, IA

The menu includes only a few items, but Pagliai's Pizza is proof, after more than five decades, that if you do something well and do it consistently, people will continue to patronize your business, year after year.

- Taylor B. - Chicago, IL

Everyone I know that grew up in Charleston and moved away HAS to get their Pagliai's Pizza fix when they come to town. They even ship the pizzas. Great sauce, sausage and crust! Their pan pizza is a new favorite. You may have to wait for a seat but it'll be worth it!

- Paula P. - Charleston, IL

After going to eat here for the last 41 years, this restaurant never fails to excel. Each time, I bring someone new to experience perfection on a pizza plate. And every time, those guests are amazed. Stop in, and let Paul and his crew treat you to something delicious.

- Charles White

Food was amazing! Best pizza I've had in a long time! I would definitely recommend!

- Penny Shinholster

We love the pizza. We enjoy having family nights here once a week!

- Leif Epperson
Share by: